Out of 13 attempts, which includes both stars and non-stars, only one player was nice enough to return one back to me.
That player, CB R.W. McQuarters.
If you don't remember, R.W. played a major role in the Giants run to Super Bowl 42 intercepting a pass in the first three rounds of the playoffs especially in the Division Round against Dallas where he intercepted Tony Romo in the end zone to end the game. He played for the Giants overall from the 2006-2008 seasons.
I sent this into R.W. right after I got the card in a pack and he sent it right back.
I actually haven't even tried to send any TTM to Giants players the last few years knowing I probably won't get lucky. But, I may try again this summer just to see. Will let you all know who I send it to and my rate of success.