How Do I Sort This?

My recent mail day from my Twitter buddy @NYCollects, not light bulbs this time (you can see that funny article on here by looking up @NYCollects), had me thinking when I go to sort this card, how do I do so?

This card has four players on it. All four play a big role in my Giants collection. Eli Manning I am closing in on 500 cards. Rueben Randle and Odell Beckham Jr have over 200 cards of each player and this is Beckham's rookie year. Andre Williams was a huge PC in terms of the amount of hits I have for him.

However, the way I sort things and mark things down, I can only choose one player. One. So which one do you think I should choose to add this card to the PC of? How would you sort this one?

Let me know in comments and a thanks again to @NYCollects for giving me this card for my collection. Your one good dude!